Rob Portman and Michelle Shocked

I’m feeling a bit less churlish than I did initially about the pronouncement by US Senator Rob Portman that he NOW supports marriage equality because his son has come out as gay, even though, previously, Portman usually got zero ratings from civil rights groups on the issue in the past. I know that SamuraiFrog was right:

“I’m seeing a lot of people who are having this very liberal reaction of ‘Well, why couldn’t he have empathy for everyone’s child?’ Well, you know, because humans are like that. They’re self-interested… Sure, it would be nice if conservatives thought about everyone else’s kids, too, but they don’t. That’s as obvious as it is frustrating.

“What I’m saying is, [the kvetching] takes away from the small victory of changing one legislator’s mind about gay people when you say that this victory isn’t big enough… a lot of times it’s just small victories that add up.

“Yes, it sucks that gay civil rights are still being discussed as though they’re privileges and not rights and fundamental to everyone’s equality. But I’m seeing too many people who should know better implying that this doesn’t matter, and I think it does. It’s one more mind changed.”

Which brings me to the alt-folk-rock singer Michelle Shocked’s anti-gay screed in San Francisco, a surprising tirade against marriage equality and homosexuality generally. Arthur@AmeriNZ, who, BTW has been documenting the marriage equality fight in New Zealand and in the US in recent weeks, wonders where does that leave her former fans, of which he was one?

(UPDATE: Here’s a bit of the actual audio of Michelle Shocked, March 17 at Yoshi’s in San Francisco.)

There have been a number of these folk, who one might have once admired but end up having feet of clay. For me, Mel Gibson was one. Fortunately, he started making movies I didn’t want to see (Passion of the Christ, e.g.) around the same time he went on his rants. I took Florence + the Machine off my Amazon wish list after a couple racist videos.

I don’t own any Michelle Shocked music, save for one great song on the Dead Man Walking soundtrack, The Quality of Mercy is Not Strained, which I’m sure I linked to in this blog; I’m surely not going to go back and remove it. But, like Arthur, I’d be as disinclined to spend another cent on her, as many comic books fans felt about the homophobic Orson Scott Card writing the Superman comic book, which, I believe, has been dashed.

BTW, I LOVE the paint job across from the Westboro Baptist Church.
Know what IS ticking me off? The damn reports after the
two high schoolers in Steubenville, OH were found guilty on Sunday of raping a 16-year-old girl. Media apologists for the rapists, who were the quarterback and star receiver for the football team, were not limited to this CNN exchange. It is as though raping someone were like your house falling into a sinkhole, some random act of nature the young men were victimized by. You know, boys will be boys. Moreover, two teenage girls were charged for allegedly threatening the rape victim. I watched on the news when the victim’s lawyer said the victim feared going back to school “on Monday, and Tuesday, and Wednesday.”

Someone I read recently (can’t remember who) suggested that we have a culture of rape. My US Senator, Kirsten Gillibrand wrote: “According to the Defense Department’s own estimates, there were approximately 19,000 instances of sexual assaults in the military in 2011 alone. Worse still, only 2,439 of those victimized felt they could come forward to report their assault, and only 240 of those cases went to trial.”
In the no-surprise category: Richard Nixon’s ‘Treason’, elements of which I heard about years ago.
While he’s busy harassing [ex-wife Maureen] McPhilmy for asserting the holiness of her second marriage, [Bill] O’Reilly is trying to deny the existence of his first: He is… seeking an annulment of his 15-year marriage, which produced two children. Null and void. Invalid in the eyes of God. Never happened. This hurts my head.
I’d just better watch Billy Joel singing, accompanied on piano by a student. Some of the snark warriors are making the rounds, but I just like this.

4 thoughts on “Rob Portman and Michelle Shocked”

  1. “Snark warriors” – I’ll have to remember that one! Not surprisingly, we’re on the same page here. My thoughts about Portman are too long for a comment, but I agree his change of heart is significant. The artist set to draw the Orson Scott Card story pulled out, citing the controversy around Card, and it’s now delayed. I wouldn’t be surprised if it just didn’t appear at all.


  2. On Howard Cruse’s FaceBook page he had a link to an online petitiion against states criminalizing Homosexuality, I don’t know how to link to it, but go to Howard’s page and sign, I did!


  3. Roger, you hit just about every hot button this week for me. Michelle Shocked, what the hell happened to her? I thought she was an OK woman… pity, she must have gotten a hit of the Kool-Aid.

    As for these “esteemed members of Congress” finally coming around to the view that people are people and it’s nobody’s business who loves whom… the ones who wait until someone in their family comes out make me puke. I’m sorry, but if they opened their eyes, they’d find LGBT folks in their pharmacies, schools, hospitals, day care centers… What is the difference? (In Washington, DC, I do believe it self-loathing, as the number of “closeted” members have the most abysmal voting records. See “Outraged,” the video, which “outs” these politicians ONLY for the sake of showing their hypocrisy. I AM NOT IN FAVOR OF OUTING PEOPLE, unless they are in a position of power, wielding their immoral authority against the very people they cannot face when they look in the mirror.

    JESUS SAID: Love one another. And I don’t want to hear any Old Testament BS about “homosexuality,” nor do I take NT use of that word seriously either. The very word “homosexual” was not invented until the 1860s, so any Bible that includes that word is a poor translation, and reflects the undereducation of its editors, at that. In Paul’s Letter to the Church in Rome (AKA Romans), there are all sorts of extra bits dropped in, including the “men gave over to… men,” etc. Paul’s epistles are rife with others’ writing in the margins.

    I am sick of my gay, lesbian, trans, and bisexual brothers and sisters being bashed in the head with Bibles and with congressional and state laws. And Bill O’Reilly, o Sanctimonious One, yeah, that’s the way, declare your own children bastards. Talk about “family values.” Amy


  4. I’m still so disappointed in Orson Scott Card. One of my favorite books was written by him. I just can’t go read anymore by him. I just can’t.

    Sharp Little Pencil said: “I am sick of my gay, lesbian, trans, and bisexual brothers and sisters being bashed in the head with Bibles and with congressional and state laws.”

    Couldn’t agree more with you there.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s